There's a grocery store in Los Angeles selling a single cup of water for $12. Not a bottle. A cup. And people are lining up to buy it. If you've wondered why Erewhon water is so expensive, and why anyone pays for it, the answer is the most useful idea in business.

We're all used to paying for water. A dollar for a bottle, a few bucks at the airport, nobody blinks. But $12 for one cup sounds absurd. The strangest part is what would happen if the store made it cheaper. Drop that same cup to $3, and people would want it less, not more. That single fact breaks the first rule of economics most of us were taught, and it points straight at perceived value, the force that quietly sets the price of everything you sell.

The $12 cup of water, explained

Erewhon is a grocery store that feels more like a nightclub for wellness. Flattering lighting, produce arranged like jewelry, celebrity smoothies, and a single strawberry that runs about $19. This summer they added a product called Sacred Water, made by a brand called Jolie: $12 for a 12-ounce cup of grape juice, coconut milk, coconut water, jasmine tea, and a few herbs. A reporter who actually tried it said it mostly just tasted like coconut water.

The internet did what it always does. People filmed the price, called it a crime, called it a scam. And then more people showed up to buy it. That reaction, outrage and demand arriving together, is the first clue that something worth understanding is happening here.

Why a higher price can create more demand

Economics 101 teaches the demand curve: raise the price, and fewer people want the thing. But there's a category of products where the line bends the other way. Economists call them Veblen goods, named after Thorstein Veblen, who noticed that some products exist mainly to signal status. Their appeal comes from being expensive. Diamonds, designer handbags, a Rolls Royce. Part of what you're buying is the fact that most people can't.

The Erewhon water works the same way. At $12 it's a sensation people film and line up for. At $3 it's just another overpriced juice in the cooler, and nobody makes a video about a $3 drink. For the customer, the price is the main feature.

This isn't only true of luxury water. When you need surgery, you don't shop for the cheapest surgeon. When a company hires a consultant, the one charging $500 an hour is often taken more seriously than the one charging $50, before either says a word. In a lot of markets, being the cheapest option quietly signals the opposite of what you're hoping for. It whispers that even you don't really believe your work is worth much.

People literally taste the price

Here's how deep perceived value goes. Jimmy Kimmel's show ran a street test where they handed people a cup, called it Erewhon's $12 Sacred Water, and asked what they thought. It was actually plain hose water from the back parking lot. People described honey, hibiscus, cucumber, a hint of avocado. One person said it had the mouthfeel of oatmeal. Another said they could feel it in their legs.

It's a comedy segment, and some reactions were surely played up for the camera. But it's close to the truth, and we have real science that says so. In a well-known Caltech study, people were given the same wine at different stated prices. The ones who thought it was expensive got measurably more pleasure from it, and you could see it on a brain scan. The price changed how good the wine actually tasted.

So a strong brand does more than change what people will pay. It changes what they experience. That's the power sitting inside a silly cup of water.

There's no such thing as objective value

We're raised to believe things have a true, correct price hidden inside them, and that a good deal means paying less than that number. But that number was never real. Peter Drucker, one of the sharpest business thinkers who ever lived, said the purpose of a business is to create a customer, and you create a customer by offering something they perceive as valuable. Perceive. The whole game lives in that one word.

Think about the same bottle of water. It's a dollar at the store, four at the airport, eight on a beach chair, and everything in your wallet if you're lost in the desert. The liquid never changes. The value swings because the story and the context around it change. Erewhon didn't find a magic spring. They built the richest story on earth around the plainest product on earth, and then charged for the story.

What a brand actually is

Most people think their brand is a logo, some colors, and a font. Those are just triggers, little cues that fire off the real thing. A brand is the story people tell themselves about why they buy.

When someone buys that $12 water, they're buying a small story about who they are. It says they take care of themselves. It says they can afford it. It says they belong. The cup is the receipt. The story is the product. And people will pay almost anything for a story that makes them feel like the person they want to be, because it's the one thing a cheaper competitor can't put in the box.

How any business can use perceived value

You might think this only works for a celebrity grocery store in LA. It works for any business, including yours. You're already selling a story, whether you chose it or not. When you don't build one, your customer defaults to the laziest story available: this is a commodity, so the cheapest option wins. That's the worst position to compete from, and most businesses live there for years.

The fix doesn't take a bigger budget. It takes three decisions.

Decide who your customer becomes when they buy from you. Not just what they get, but who they get to be. A coffee drinker becomes a person with good taste and a calmer morning. A painting client becomes a responsible homeowner protecting what they built. That identity is the real product.

Name the villain in your industry and stand against it. A burger spot that grinds fresh meat every morning can stand against the frozen patty trucked in from a warehouse 1,000 miles away. Give your customer something to be for and something to be against, and the contrast gives your story its heat.

Obsess over the details your customer actually feels. The lighting, the greeting, the weight of the packaging, the small unexpected touch at the end. A coffee shop that names the farm, roasts in the window, and learns your order sells a $5 ritual instead of a $2 cup. A painter who shows up in clean uniforms and leaves the place spotless sells peace of mind, not gallons. Same product, better story, and people happily pay more for it.

The one rule: your product has to deliver

Perceived value is powerful enough to get you in trouble, so here's the rule that keeps it honest. Once you accept that value is a story, it's tempting to think the product stops mattering. It matters more than ever. A story only holds up if the product underneath can carry the weight.

What Erewhon gets right, under all the silliness, is that it delivers on its story. The lighting really is beautiful. The produce really is stunning. The staff really are helpful. The whole place makes you feel like you stepped into a nicer version of your life. The $12 water is ridiculous, but the world around it is real, and the story matches the experience. The day those two stop matching, the whole thing collapses, because a customer who feels tricked tells everyone and never comes back.

So build your story on purpose, charge what it's honestly worth, and make sure that when your customer opens the box, walks through your door, or takes the first sip, what they get lives up to every word that brought them there. Do that, and you'll stop competing on price.

Frequently asked questions

Why is Erewhon water so expensive? The $12 price pays for perceived value, not the water itself. The brand, the store experience, and the status of buying it are what people are really paying for. The water is close to a commodity, so almost the entire price is the story around it.

What is a Veblen good? A Veblen good is a product whose demand goes up as the price goes up, because the high price signals status. Luxury goods like designer bags and, in this case, $12 water behave this way. Lowering the price would make them less desirable, not more.

How can a small business use perceived value? Decide who your customer becomes when they buy from you, stand against the tired old way of doing things in your industry, and obsess over the details people actually feel. Those choices raise perceived value without changing the underlying product, so you can charge more and stop competing on price.

Does raising your price always increase demand? No. This only works when a higher price credibly signals status or quality, and when the experience delivers on that promise. A higher price on a product that disappoints just loses customers faster.

Stop competing on price

The Erewhon $12 water is a funny story, but the lesson under it is serious. Value is a story people tell themselves, and you get to decide what story your business tells. Choose it on purpose, make your product earn it, and price becomes the last thing your customers argue about.

If you want help figuring out the story your business should be telling, that's what I do as a fractional CMO at Aidia Marketing. Book a call and let's find the idea that lets you stop competing on price.

Remember: you don't need to buy more ads when you have better ideas.

About the author: Brent Shiratori is a fractional CMO who runs Aidia Marketing, where he helps business owners turn marketing into a driver of revenue. 

Watch more on YouTube.